Butler Pappas Home

As we litigate a case in the trial court, we are always mindful of the outlook on appeal. Sometimes our objective is to protect a victory from upset. Sometimes, it is to preserve an error for appeal. At other times it is the goal of our Client, from the outset, to change or shape the law by creating precedent. We welcome such challenges and are proud of our achievements. We can handle all matters in the higher courts, state and federal, including the United States Supreme Court.
For more than thirty years, we've built a national reputation as a bulwark against insurance fraud. We've done this by winning trials. We've done this by drafting legislation and policy language. Furthermore we've done this as leaders of organizations that educate the insurance industry about the means to thwart the billion dollar economic drain that is arson and insurance fraud.
Liability exposure is as broad as human endeavor. Our casualty defense practice encompasses that vast field. We'll promptly evaluate the case and plan the best course, be it settlement, mediation, arbitration or trial. Then we'll execute.
Occasionally a new field of defense litigation springs to life overnight. When the "Chinese Drywall" phenomenon erupted, we assembled a team with expertise in construction, insurance coverage, and product liability cases. Our Chinese Drywall team dispenses informed advice and litigates the full range of legal exposures including the availability of coverage for property damage and liability.
Our construction lawyers are prepared to handle any aspect of litigation, from initial contract and bid proposals, to material failures and construction defects, to disputes surrounding final certifications. We routinely represent owners, developers, design professionals and manufacturers, as well as general and sub-contractors. Butler Pappas prides itself on having real world experience in the construction field by understanding industry standards and building practices.
For decades, we've counseled clients on sophisticated coverage questions. With this institutional knowledge in place, we're efficient at providing fast opinions on the most complex issues. And, when litigation ensues, our experience serves our clients well.
Claims for the breach of sensitive private data systems are complex and require a quick response. Our cyber loss team counsels clients on first and third party coverage questions relating to system invasions and data breaches. We assist insurers and their insureds in responding to these situations. We also defend companies, who have been victimized by cyber attacks, from third party claims. For some clients, we recover money they had to pay for such losses.
We are able to assist management and human resource teams in the prevention of employment-related claims. Still, when such claims do occur, we defend them at the administrative level and in the courts.
We have the experience and resources to defend high exposure, "bet-the-company" suits. These include actions for first and third-party "bad faith," and all manner of damages in excess of insurance policy limits. In such matters, we believe ourselves to be preeminent.
Patents, trademarks, copyrights and trade secrets: Intellectual property may be among a company's most valuable assets. Butler Pappas counsels clients how best to preserve and protect those assets. Our services include the defense and prosecution of lawsuits for infringement, dilution, unfair competition and misappropriation, as well as cybersquatting and domain name disputes.
We help assess and manage professional liability to prevent or eliminate claims as well as providing a defense before professional standards boards and when matters are tried in court.
We assess and help mitigate the costs and risks of product liability claims. Indeed, we manage all manner of product problems at the regulatory level and in litigation. Our expertise puts us at the forefront as speakers and planners of national programs on product liability.
We help manufacturers, suppliers, retailers and their insurers take the necessary precautions to prevent a costly product recall. We assist clients in reporting safety issues to applicable government agencies, as well as deciding when and how to recall products. While no manufacturer ever wants its products recalled, we can help minimize potential exposure, so our clients can get back to business. And if necessary, we provide litigation support against claims resulting from allegedly defective products.
Butler Pappas attorneys handle matters and disputes for ceding insurers, reinsurers, and retrocessionaires. Our services include reviewing reinsurance treaties, advising on coverage disputes, litigation, arbitration and mediation, as well as collections for cedents and reinsurers, including cases of insolvency.
One of our great strengths is large loss subrogation and recovery. Being on "first call" for an investigation lets us preserve evidence and position the matter for recovery from the outset. We have access to prime experts in many fields, and we, ourselves, put tremendous time and effort into understanding the scientific and engineering side of every case.
Butler Pappas brings years of combined experience to bear in the defense of trucking accidents. A rapid deployment team of attorneys and paralegals can be on the scene of an accident within hours to protect the company, its drivers and valuable evidence. Our team has access to a strong database of established experts with expertise in accident reconstruction, photography, videography, regulatory compliance, conspicuity and hazardous waste containment.

Contact Us

Home

David H. Shaw, II

Bio Image

To get a print copy of this attorney's biographical information, please download a convenient PDF.

Tampa

Senior Associate

Phone

(813) 281-1900

Address

777 S. Harbour Island Boulevard
#500
Tampa, Florida
33602

Email

dshaw@butlerpappas.com

Practice Areas

Arson & Fraud
Coverage Defense
Extra-Contractual

Education

University of Florida
Stetson University College of Law

Download

David's v-Card David's Bio PDF

David H. Shaw, II is a Senior Associate at Butler Pappas.

He devotes his practice to first party property coverage. Prior to joining Butler Pappas, David developed his civil litigation experience defending various clients in third-party liability litigation, which included mediating numerous cases, as well as, defending some of his clients at trial.

David is a member of The Florida Bar and the Hillsborough County Bar Association. He has been admitted to practice before the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals, the United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida and all Florida State Courts.

David earned his Juris Doctorate degree, cum laude, from Stetson University College of Law in December 2001. While at Stetson University College of Law, David also participated in the dual J.D./M.B.A. program and earned his Master of Business Administration degree in December 2001. Prior to his legal education, David earned a Bachelor of Science degree from the University of Florida in Business Management. Upon graduating from Stetson College of Law, David received the William F. Blews Pro Bono Service Award and was nominated for inclusion into the National Deans List.

Publications

Case Types

Bankruptcy
CGL
Civil Remedy Notices
Commercial Litigation
Construction Defect Litigation
Coverage - First Party Property
Coverage - Property
Engineering Malpractice
Homeowner's - Insurance
Malpractice - Architecture
Malpractice - Engineering
Negligent Supervision
Premises Liability
Professional Liability
Professional Malpractice - Engineering/Architecture
Real Estate Litigation
Standard Liability
Subrogation - Large Loss
Third Party Liability